SEO Audit Guide: The Complete Guide to Running an SEO Audit

If a tree falls in a forest and nobody is around to hear it, does it make a sound?

If a website is developed, designed, and published to the internet, yet nobody ever visits it, does the website exist at all?

An SEO audit is more than a routine check-up; it’s a strategic deep-dive into the health of your site. It uncovers hidden technical issues, missed content opportunities, and backlink weaknesses that can quietly sabotage your rankings. Whether you’re an in-house marketer, an agency, or a business owner trying to stay ahead of competitors, an audit gives you a data-backed roadmap to improve performance and grow organic traffic.

And today, SEO auditing is evolving fast.

With the rise of large language models (LLMs) and AI-powered SEO tools, what used to take days can now be automated and enhanced with incredible precision.

But while the machines are getting smarter, successful audits still demand human strategy and business context in order to avoid things like SEO multiplicity and content redundancy.

In this ultimate guide, we’ll walk you through the complete process of conducting a comprehensive SEO audit—from technical crawl to AI-assisted content analysis—so you can diagnose, prioritize, and optimize with confidence.

Ensuring that your website stays as near to the first search result as possible is as simple as ensuring that you have the proper SEO. The first step in doing that is to have someone perform an SEO audit of your website. visit – Best SEO audit Tools

Why Your Website Needs an Audit

Here are a few warning signs that your website does, without a doubt, need an SEO audit and competitor analysis:

1. Your Website Doesn’t Get as Many Visitors as It Once Did

2. A Search Engine Algorithm Change

3. Only a Small Portion of Your Traffic Comes from Search Engines

4. Pay-Per-Click is Horrendously Expensive

5. Your Visitors Aren’t Converting to Customers

6. Your Website Is Not Listed on the First Page of Google

7. Your Visitors Aren’t Staying

8. Website Traffic Seems to Have Reached a Maximum

9. You Have a Number of Long-Tail Keyword Hits

10. Your Traffic Originates Mainly from No-Follow Websites

Before diving into tools, checklists, or crawl reports, it’s important to understand why an SEO audit matters.

An SEO audit is the foundational process of analyzing a website’s ability to appear in search engine results.

It’s about identifying what’s broken, what’s underperforming, and what opportunities you’re missing—all so you can take informed action to boost rankings, traffic, and conversions.

Full SEO audits should be conducted regularly – ideally according to a documented schedule. But if you’ve never conducted a site audit before and aren’t sure if the timing is right, we’ve compiled a list of relevant symptoms that indicate it’s time.

Key Objectives of an SEO Audit:

• Uncover Technical Roadblocks:
  Search engines rely on clean, crawlable code and well-structured pages. An audit helps identify problems like broken links, slow page speed, improper redirects, or crawl errors that could be hurting your visibility without you even knowing.

• Improve Content Relevance and Quality:
  Not all content is created equal. Some pages may be competing with each other (keyword cannibalization), while others are thin, outdated, or off-topic. A good audit highlights what needs to be removed, refreshed, or re-optimized.

• Evaluate Backlink Health:
  Toxic backlinks and poor anchor text distribution can negatively affect your domain authority. An SEO audit digs into your link profile to ensure it’s helping—not hurting—your performance.

• Stay Ahead of Algorithm Changes:
  SEO is not static. Google’s algorithm updates can reshape the search landscape overnight. Regular audits help you remain compliant and adaptive as search engines evolve.

• Align SEO with Business Goals:
  Are your top-ranking pages converting? Is your content targeting the right customer intent? An SEO audit aligns technical performance with business objectives—because traffic without conversions is just vanity.

In short, an SEO audit isn’t about vanity metrics or checking a box. It’s about creating a measurable, prioritized action plan to turn your website into a high-performing, revenue-generating asset.

Pre-Audit Checklist: Benchmark Current Performance

You need a baseline to measure improvement. Use tools like:

• Google Analytics (traffic trends, bounce rate, conversions)

• Google Search Console (indexing issues, click-through rate, average positions)

• Ahrefs / SEMrush / Moz (domain authority, backlink profile, keyword rankings)

Snapshot your current visibility so you can compare post-audit gains.

Technical SEO Audit

The technical side of SEO is like your website’s plumbing—when it’s working, no one notices.

But when it breaks, everything downstream suffers. A technical SEO audit is the first critical step in uncovering structural issues that prevent search engines from crawling, indexing, and ranking your site properly.

Even the best content in the world won’t perform if it’s hidden behind crawl errors or page speed problems.

Key Areas to Audit in Technical SEO:

1. Crawlability and Indexability

• Run a crawl using tools like Screaming Frog, Sitebulb, or DeepCrawl.

• Look for:

  • Broken internal links (404s)

  • Crawl errors

  • Orphaned pages (pages with no internal links pointing to them)

  • Pages blocked by robots.txt or noindex tags

Search engines can’t rank what they can’t find.

2. Site Architecture and URL Structure

• Ensure a clean, hierarchical site structure.

• Limit your click depth—important pages should be accessible within 2–3 clicks from the homepage.

• Use keyword-relevant, human-readable URLs.

Example:
yourdomain.com/seo-services/

yourdomain.com/page?id=872

3. Mobile-Friendliness

• Over 60% of searches come from mobile devices.

• Use Google’s Mobile-Friendly Test to ensure responsiveness.

• Check for:

  • Touch element spacing

  • Readable fonts

  • Viewport configuration

4. Page Speed and Core Web Vitals

Load times are now a ranking factor.

Use Google PageSpeed Insights, Lighthouse, or WebPageTest.

• Key metrics to monitor:

  • Largest Contentful Paint (LCP)

  • First Input Delay (FID)

  • Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS)

Fix issues like render-blocking resources, uncompressed images, or excessive JavaScript.

5. HTTPS and Site Security

• Make sure your entire site uses HTTPS.

• Check for mixed content errors (secure and non-secure resources on the same page).

• Ensure SSL certificates are valid and auto-renew.

6. Redirects and Canonicals

• Audit 301 and 302 redirects for efficiency and relevance.

• Look for redirect chains and loops.

• Ensure canonical tags are in place to prevent duplicate content issues.

7. XML Sitemap and Robots.txt

• Ensure your XML sitemap is:

  • Submitted to Google Search Console

  • Dynamically updated

  • Clean (no 404s or redirects)

• Review your robots.txt file to avoid accidentally blocking important pages.

A well-run technical audit sets the foundation for everything else in your SEO strategy. Without it, you’re building on unstable ground—and Google has no patience for broken architecture.

On-Page SEO Audit

While technical SEO gets your site crawled and indexed, on-page SEO is what tells search engines what your content is about—and whether it’s worth ranking.

An on-page SEO audit ensures that every page on your site is optimized for search intent, structured correctly, and aligned with best practices for both users and bots.

What to Review in an On-Page SEO Audit

1. Page Titles and Meta Descriptions

• Titles should include your primary keyword, be under 60 characters, and be unique to each page.

• Meta descriptions aren’t a ranking factor, but they do influence click-through rates. Keep them under 155 characters, compelling, and relevant.

• Flag duplicate or missing metadata using your crawler tool.

2. Headings and Content Structure

• Each page should have one <h1> tag, clearly describing the main topic.

• Use <h2>, <h3>, etc., to break up content logically.

• Headings should include secondary and semantic keywords without stuffing.

3. Keyword Optimization

• Is your target keyword placed naturally in:

  • Title tag?

  • H1?

  • First 100 words?

  • URL?

  • Image alt text?

• Avoid keyword stuffing. Instead, focus on semantic SEO using related phrases and entities that support topic relevance (use tools like Clearscope or Surfer SEO).

4. Internal Linking

• Ensure strategic internal links point to key pages.

• Use descriptive anchor text (not just “click here”).

• Fix broken internal links and eliminate orphaned content.

• LLM tools can now suggest internal link opportunities based on semantic relevance—not just matching anchor phrases.

5. Image Optimization

• All images should:

  • Be compressed without quality loss

  • Have descriptive, keyword-relevant alt tags

  • Use modern formats (e.g., WebP)

• File names should reflect image content (seo-audit-chart.png instead of IMG_8483.jpg).

6. Duplicate Content

• Use tools like Siteliner, Copyscape, or Semrush to identify duplicate or near-duplicate content across your site.

• Consolidate, canonicalize, or rewrite pages that overlap.

7. Schema Markup (Structured Data)

• Implement schema.org markup for:

  • Articles/blogs

  • Products/services

  • Local business info

  • FAQs and how-to guides

• Use Google’s Rich Results Test to validate markup and enhance SERP appearance.

When done right, an on-page audit gives each page the best possible chance to rank—and converts more users once they land.

Even better, modern AI and LLM tools can accelerate this process with intelligent suggestions, helping you prioritize pages and content sections that offer the most ROI.

How Often to Run the Audit

Chances are, unless you have a full team of people making regular edits to your website, you won’t need to run this audit often. Your titles and descriptions are static, not dynamic, so once you make a change, that change will likely stay.

However, if you have a habit of adding new pages or deleting old ones, or if you’re launching a new site, it’s imperative that you run a new  site audit to make sure that your new site layout is still in compliance with best practices.

Generally, running this once every two or three months is ample.

Content Audit

Whether you’re not getting the results you were anticipating or you’re just trying to reevaluate your brand’s direction, a content marketing audit is invaluable in helping you find key areas for change and improvement. While each written post is unique, requiring in-depth research in addition to drafting and revision, most content strategies, on the whole, run on autopilot. The general direction is set, and the individual moving parts that carry out the work simply repeat the same tasks over and over.

Unlike a simple keyword checklist, a modern content audit should also assess semantic depth, user engagement, and how well your pages satisfy search intent.

Goals of a Content Audit

• Identify high-performing content to preserve and promote

• Find underperforming pages to improve or remove

• Discover content gaps and opportunities

• Prevent keyword cannibalization and internal competition

• Improve alignment with user intent and marketing funnel stages

Key Steps in a Content Audit:

1. Inventory Your Existing Content

• Export URLs, titles, traffic, bounce rates, and conversion data using tools like:

  • Google Analytics

  • Google Search Console

  • Screaming Frog (crawl + data extraction)

• Create a centralized spreadsheet or dashboard to tag and track every page.

2. Evaluate Performance Metrics

• Metrics to consider:

  • Organic traffic trends

  • Average time on page

  • Bounce rate

  • Conversion rate

  • Keyword rankings and impressions

• Flag pages with low or no visibility as candidates for consolidation, rewriting, or pruning.

3. Detect Content Cannibalization

• Multiple pages targeting the same keyword? That’s cannibalization.

• Use tools like Ahrefs or Semrush to spot overlapping rankings.

• Solutions:

  • Consolidate content into one authoritative piece

  • Adjust keyword targeting per page

  • Use canonical tags or 301 redirects where needed

4. Refresh & Optimize Underperforming Content

• Update stats, dates, links, and examples

• Add visual content (images, videos, charts)

• Improve internal linking and CTAs

• Reassess keyword targeting using modern tools like Clearscope, Surfer, or MarketMuse

5. Use LLMs and AI to Assist in Content Evaluation

• AI tools can analyze thousands of pages faster than humans, offering:

  • Semantic keyword gap analysis

  • Suggested outlines and content enhancements

  • Detection of thin content or duplicate phrasing

  • Intelligent rephrasing for improved clarity and readability

• LLMs can even help repackage content across funnel stages—turning a blog post into a lead magnet, FAQ, or video script.

6. Identify Content Gaps and Opportunities

• Run a topic cluster analysis to identify missing content in your topical authority map.

• Use tools like AnswerThePublic, AlsoAsked, or LLM-powered clustering models to surface FAQs and long-tail topics your audience is actively searching for.

• Benchmark against competitors to discover high-traffic pages you don’t yet have.

A content audit isn’t just about SEO—it’s about sharpening your brand message, improving engagement, and driving more conversions. With AI tools now capable of accelerating and enriching this process, there’s no excuse to let stale, fragmented content drag down your rankings.

Link Quality Audit

Link building is still a viable and necessary strategy for SEO.

External links pointing to a domain pass authority to that domain, and the more authority a domain has, the easier it will be able to rank for specific keywords.

Unfortunately, the link-building process is more complex than just posting links on external sites; Google’s Penguin update, which was originally released in 2012, has made the link-identifying components of Google’s search algorithm incredibly sophisticated.

Its most recent iteration, 3.0 in October of this year, pushed those changes even further. Under Penguin, your external links need to be diverse, authoritative, and of high quality.

Otherwise, you could face a penalty and suffer a ranking drop instead of a boost.

As a result, it’s important to perform an occasional link quality site audit to review your overall strategy, identify possible weaknesses, and prevent the possibility of getting hit with a sudden ranking fall.

Many search marketers know this information, but still, fail to perform a site audit regularly.

This guide will help you understand not only when—but also how—to perform a link quality site audit for your campaign.

AI & LLMs in Modern SEO Audits

The SEO landscape is changing fast—and artificial intelligence is no longer just a futuristic concept. With the rise of large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4, Claude, and open-source alternatives, SEO audits are becoming more intelligent, efficient, and predictive than ever before.

But while AI can dramatically enhance the audit process, it’s not a magic wand. Understanding what LLMs can (and can’t) do is key to using them effectively.

How LLMs Are Enhancing SEO Audits

1. Semantic Content Analysis

LLMs excel at understanding context and relationships between topics. When auditing content, AI can:

• Identify gaps in topical coverage

• Surface related entities and semantically relevant terms

• Detect thin content based on depth and comprehensiveness

• Recommend improvements for E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trust)

Tools like MarketMuse, Surfer SEO, and custom GPT agents can now generate real-time content scores, outlines, and keyword clusters based on your existing pages.

2. Keyword & Topic Clustering at Scale

Traditionally, clustering thousands of keywords into topic groups was a manual or spreadsheet-driven process. LLMs make this easier by:

• Automatically grouping keywords by semantic intent

• Identifying pillar topics and supporting cluster content

• Prioritizing clusters based on search volume and competition

This improves internal linking, topical authority, and on-site structure—all critical for modern SEO.

3. Intelligent Internal Linking Suggestions

LLMs can analyze large volumes of content and suggest internal links where human reviewers might miss them—based not just on matching anchor text, but on semantic similarity.

For example, it might recommend linking a blog post about “content audits” to another about “SEO content strategies,” even if the keywords don’t exactly match, but the intent does.

4. Technical SEO Automation with AI

While LLMs aren’t ideal for parsing server logs or crawling a site like Screaming Frog, they can:

• Interpret crawl data and provide actionable summaries

• Flag problematic patterns across titles, meta descriptions, and headings

• Write regex expressions for redirects, canonicals, and site scripts

• Generate structured data markup (schema.org) with minimal human input

5. Predictive SEO & Forecasting

Using machine learning models trained on search trends and historical site data, AI tools can:

• Predict which pages are likely to lose rankings

• Forecast traffic impact from specific content updates

• Simulate outcomes from backlink gains or technical fixes

This shifts SEO audits from reactive to proactive—helping you focus on what will drive future performance.

Limitations of AI in SEO Audits

While powerful, LLMs still have blind spots:

• Hallucinations: AI may suggest tactics that sound right but lack grounding in SEO best practices.

• Lack of real-time data: Most LLMs can’t access live crawl or traffic data unless integrated with APIs.

• Nuance and judgment: AI can recommend actions, but human SEO strategists still provide the business context, prioritization, and creative direction.

Best Practices: Human + AI Collaboration

• Use AI to accelerate and scale analysis, but not replace critical thinking.

• Automate low-value, time-intensive tasks (like meta rewrites or cluster mapping).

• Validate AI outputs with manual review and expert oversight.

• Consider building your own private LLM SEO agent—trained on your brand voice, target audience, and historical data.

The Future: AI-Native SEO Workflows

As search engines themselves become increasingly AI-powered (think: Google SGE and Bing AI), your audit processes must evolve too. Embracing LLMs now positions your team ahead of the curve—not just in how you fix problems, but how you find them in the first place.

SEO Audit GUIDE Checklist

Even the best-laid content plans can go awry, especially if you haven’t touched base with your original vision from the beginning of the year, but it’s not a problem unless you allow it to keep getting worse. This is your chance to evaluate your performance, take note of possibilities for improvement, and start the new year off with a bold new approach.

The problem for most people is scale—“content marketing” refers to a lot of different moving parts, so how can you run an audit of everything all at once? That’s why I came up with this checklist. It’s not perfect, but it will help you touch on the most important points of your campaign and figure out exactly what you need to do to improve in the coming year:

Evaluate Your Overall Efforts

Next, take a look at the efforts you made to achieve those goals.

• How often did you publish content?
• What types of content did you publish? For most goals, the more variety you have the better.
• Where did you publish content? Make a list of your primary and secondary syndication channels, and whether you syndicated older material in addition to new features.
• Were there any gaps or missteps in your strategy?
• Did your strategy align with your objectives?
• Did you adjust your strategy throughout the year? This is crucial; if your strategy remained stagnant, you could have missed out on some serious opportunities for growth.
• What could you have done better? This is a broad question, and one we’ll answer in more detail with the other sections, but make a preliminary list.

Ongoing Monitoring and Re-Auditing

SEO is not a one-time event—it’s a continuous process. Search engines evolve. Competitors publish. Algorithms update. Your site needs to adapt accordingly. That’s why ongoing monitoring and regular re-audits are essential to keeping your SEO strategy sharp and your rankings strong.

Think of this step as your long-term maintenance plan—it’s how you sustain (and build upon) the improvements from your initial audit.

Why You Need to Monitor SEO Continuously

• Algorithm changes happen often. Google releases hundreds of updates per year. Without active monitoring, your traffic can tank overnight without warning.

• New technical issues can emerge. Site updates, plugins, or hosting changes can introduce new crawl errors, speed issues, or mobile UX problems.

• Content decay is real. Great posts today may become irrelevant or outdated six months from now. Traffic and rankings drop if content isn’t refreshed.

• Competitors don’t sit still. If they’re investing in better content, faster pages, or stronger backlink profiles, you’ll lose ground without ongoing action.

How to Monitor SEO Performance in Real Time

Set up tools and workflows to catch issues as they arise:

• Google Search Console

  • Monitor indexing, page experience, and URL inspection errors

  • Track performance by page, query, country, and device

• Google Analytics 4

  • Measure engagement, conversions, and behavioral flow

• Rank tracking tools (Ahrefs, Semrush, AccuRanker)

  • Monitor keyword fluctuations and SERP feature visibility

• Uptime & crawl monitoring (Pingdom, Screaming Frog Scheduled Crawls)

  • Get alerts on downtime, broken pages, or sudden crawl spikes

Bonus: Set up AI-driven alert systems to flag unusual traffic dips, crawl anomalies, or declining keyword clusters before they become critical.

When to Re-Audit Your Site

A good rule of thumb is to perform a comprehensive SEO audit every 3–6 months, or immediately after:

• A major site migration or redesign

• A sudden drop in organic traffic

• A known algorithm update (e.g., Core or Spam Update)

• A shift in your product/service offering

Even without major changes, recurring audits uncover creeping technical debt, outdated pages, or link decay that slowly erode your rankings over time.

Make SEO Auditing a Habit, Not a Fire Drill

The best-performing websites treat SEO auditing like preventive care—not emergency response.

• Bake audits into your quarterly marketing plan

• Use AI tools to automate low-level monitoring

• Assign an owner (internal or agency) responsible for SEO health

• Maintain a living SEO scorecard with tracked KPIs

Pro tip: If you’re using AI tools or your own internal LLMs, create scheduled workflows that continuously scan for new issues in metadata, content performance, or semantic gaps—so your audit becomes self-refreshing.

Major Benefits Of The SEO Audit

An SEO audit is an important task that should be carried out regularly in order to maintain a good ranking in search engines. There are many benefits of SEO audits, including improved website visibility, increased traffic, and higher conversion rates.

1. SEO audits to ensure that your website is visible to the search engines. If your website is not visible to the search engines, then it will not be able to attract any organic traffic. An SEO audit can help to identify any issues that are preventing your website from being indexed by search engines. Once these issues have been fixed, your website will start to appear in the search results, which will in turn lead to more traffic.

2. SEO audits can help to increase your website’s traffic. By making your website more visible in the search results, an SEO audit can help to increase the amount of traffic that your website receives. This can lead to more sales and conversions, as well as improved brand awareness.

3. SEO audits can improve your website’s conversion rate. If more people are visiting your website, then there is a greater chance that some of them will take the desired action, such as making a purchase or signing up for a newsletter. By improving your website’s visibility and traffic levels, an on page SEO audit can help to increase your conversion rate.

4. SEO audits can help to improve your website’s overall performance. An on page SEO audit can help to improve your website’s overall performance. This can lead to a better user experience and improved search engine results.

Build a Visual SEO Audit Report

Executives and stakeholders won’t sift through 80-page audits. Use dashboards and visuals to convey the data:

• SEO health score (overall site grade)

• Issue distribution by category

• Historical benchmarks vs. post-fix projections

• Before-and-after rankings or traffic deltas

Tools like Looker Studio, Google Sheets, or SEO audit platforms like Sitebulb and Screaming Frog can help visualize findings clearly.

SEO Audit Next Steps

Okay, clearly you need an SEO audit.

The question is, how do you conduct an SEO audit and competitor analysis? Without digging too deep into the technical aspects – that’s a conversation for another day – here are some of the key steps involved in the process:

• Look for glaring issues. The very first phase of an SEO audit is to look for any major issues that are causing significant problems for your website. For example, verify that there’s only one version of your website that’s able to be browsed. You must also verify that your website is in fact indexed by Google.
• Uncover the easy fixes. Once you’ve identified and dealt with any glaring issues, you can go after the easy fixes – the low-hanging fruit, per se. Do all of your pages have meta descriptions? Does each page only have one H1 tag with proper subheaders? Is there any duplicate content holding your site back?
• Analyze your traffic with google analytics. Review your google analytics and dig deep into your traffic reports. Which landing pages are responsible for bringing in the most search traffic? Are there one or two pages responsible for a huge chunk of traffic, or are there even distribution?
• Conduct a backlink analysis. Are your backlinks using the correct version of your website’s domain? Is the anchor text spelled correctly? Are there any spammy websites that you’d prefer not to be associated with? A thorough backlink analysis will help you uncover answers to all of these questions.
• Research the competition. Competitor research is a major part of any SEO audit. Take the time to develop a list of your biggest competitors and then use some competitor analysis tools to see what keywords they rank for, how their pages are performing, etc.
• Audit your content. Once you have an idea of what keywords the competition is ranking for and how they’re performing on the SEO front, revisit your own content and conduct an audit. More specifically, look for content gaps. These are keywords that your competitors rank for, but that you don’t. Consider revising your current content to include these keywords, as well as creating fresh content around relevant topics in these niches.

SEO.co: Your Source for Quality Content and Link Building

At SEO.co, we specialize in supplying businesses with high-quality content marketing and white-label link-building for agencies.

But we’ll also be the first to admit that these services will benefit your company very little if your website doesn’t have a strong SEO foundation to support it.

Before investing in link building, we’d recommend conducting a deep SEO site audit.

In doing so, you’ll uncover the issues that are holding you back and come face-to-face with promising opportunities.

In the end, this will enhance your link-building efforts and give your website the best chance of thriving!

• Author
• Recent Posts

Timothy Carter

Chief Revenue Officer at SEO Company

Industry veteran Timothy Carter is SEO.co’s Chief Revenue Officer. Tim leads all revenue for the company and oversees all customer-facing teams for SEO (search engine optimization) services - including sales, marketing & customer success. He has spent more than 20 years in the world of SEO & Digital Marketing, assisting in everything from SEO for lawyers to complex technical SEO for Fortune 500 clients like Wiley, Box.com, Qualtrics and HP.

Tim holds expertise in building and scaling sales operations, helping companies increase revenue efficiency and drive growth from websites and sales teams.

When he's not working, Tim enjoys playing a few rounds of disc golf, running, and spending time with his wife and family on the beach...preferably in Hawaii.

Over the years he's written for publications like Forbes, Entrepreneur, Marketing Land, Search Engine Journal, ReadWrite and other highly respected online publications. Connect with Tim on Linkedin & Twitter.

Latest posts by Timothy Carter (see all)

• New Website Launch Checklist - October 6, 2025
• Ultimate Local SEO Checklist - September 29, 2025
• Brand Storytelling: How to Capture & Keep Your Ideal Customers - September 26, 2025